Black Friday and the Failed Customer Experience

Tired of the relentless Black Friday hype? It's not just you. This once one-day shopping spree has morphed into a confusing, drawn-out affair. Originating in the 1950s US, Black Friday's global spread seemed like a win for deal-seeking shoppers. However, it's now more about boosting retail profits over an extended period. This shift dilutes its original purpose of adding value to customer experiences. Instead, it leaves many shoppers disappointed, erodes trust with misleading 'discounts', and fails to foster customer loyalty. Amidst financial strains, customers are scrutinizing deals more closely, and some are opting for Buy Nothing Days or #OptOutside movements. It's time for businesses to refocus on genuine customer relationships and experiences, moving away from revenue-driven tactics to truly enrich the holiday season.

Tired of the relentless Black Friday hype? It's not just you. This once one-day shopping spree has morphed into a confusing, drawn-out affair. Originating in the 1950s US, Black Friday's global spread seemed like a win for deal-seeking shoppers. However, it's now more about boosting retail profits over an extended period. This shift dilutes its original purpose of adding value to customer experiences. Instead, it leaves many shoppers disappointed, erodes trust with misleading 'discounts', and fails to foster customer loyalty. Amidst financial strains, customers are scrutinizing deals more closely, and some are opting for Buy Nothing Days or #OptOutside movements. It's time for businesses to refocus on genuine customer relationships and experiences, moving away from revenue-driven tactics to truly enrich the holiday season.

Author : Allison McKeever

20 November 2023
Customer Experience

You’re tired of it too, right? Black Friday sales with messages like, ‘Don’t wait, Don’t miss out, Hurry up, Limited styles, Limited quantities,’ leaving you confused about how Halloween came and went, and worrying about all those Thanksgiving leftovers in your fridge. Only to realize, ‘Wait, it’s the beginning of October, retailers need to calm down.’

Black Friday, a holiday originating in the United States in the 1950’s, now has adoption around the globe. That’s good news for holiday shoppers who want to maximize their purchasing power through discounted merchandise, or at least you’d think so.

The now-annual tradition has devolved into a confusing, multi-month-long promotional campaign. And in that descent, it has lost its original intent. What was once a day of retailers adding value to their customers’ experiences through holiday savings is now about maximizing retailers’ revenue – for a longer and longer period of time.

With all the fervor around Black “Friday”, and the expansive list of actual days that surround it, where do we find customers? This shopping phenomena has completely lost the customer thread, eroding trust in brands. Customers and employees – the bedrock of your customer experience – are metaphorically (and literally, for that matter) dying, along the way.

Customers are Disappointed

Black Friday is engineered to leave a portion of customers disappointed in the outcomes of their shopping experience. Retailers list the most desirable items at a deep discount, which drives foot traffic yet leads to a shortage as demand outweighs supply. Customers who weren’t able to get their hands on the season’s latest and greatest have to settle for their next best option, amidst an angry mob of shoppers.

“Discounts” Create a Lack of Trust

In a year when consumers feel pressure on their personal finances due to high costs of living and inflation, they’re paying closer attention to prices. A 2019 study conducted by Which?, a consumer research group, found that 83 items on sale during Black Friday were cheaper or available at the same price at other times of the year. Consumers who realize that Black Friday “deals” aren’t really deals, can erode trust in a brand.

Black Friday Doesn’t Breed Loyal Customers

You got customers in the door, and they may or may not have gotten what they wanted at a  price that may or may not have been the best. How valuable is that customer? According to a study fielded by Shopify, 64% of retailers say the customers acquired over the Black Friday weekend have a lower lifetime value than customers acquired at any other time of the year.

Seems like it’s time to rethink, no? Is your business too reliant on the revenue influx to make a change? As tough as it may be, the long term benefit of an overhaul is clearly in our collective sights. Buy Nothing Days and #OptOutside are evidence of the change to come. It starts with a well planned, omni-channel customer relationship for your business, along with a true commitment to experience above all. This holistic worldview will lead to better outcomes for both the customer and the business in time. We’re ready to have our holidays back for the relationships and relaxation they once represented!

  1. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/science/why-black-friday-leads-shoppers-to-behave-bonkers
  2. https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbesbusinesscouncil/2023/09/22/how-to-prepare-for-black-friday-and-cyber-monday/?sh=3e6397e46623
  3. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/nov/26/black-friday-uk-discounts-genuine-which
  4. https://www.retailcustomerexperience.com/blogs/black-friday-taking-advantage-of-high-consumer-engagement-for-future-wins/

Update From Blog

Why Innovation Efforts Fail

Innovation in business often stumbles, with 94% of leaders dissatisfied and 80-90% of innovation labs failing, according to McKinsey and Capgemini. This article identifies six key failure modes: wrong ideas, risky bets, ineffective funding, inadequate team knowledge, difficulty transitioning from concept to product, and lack of supportive leadership and culture. Rutabaga addresses these challenges by aligning organizations with customer needs, fostering a customer-centric culture essential for successful innovation in today's dynamic market.

Day in the Life of a Founder: A Journey of Mastery and Gratitude

Dwayne discusses his journey of entrepreneurship, explored through a lens of mastery and gratitude. Founding Rutabaga, the he faces the challenge of sprinting a marathon, learning to wear multiple hats, and navigating the fundraising rollercoaster. Each day brings growth, resilience, and a deep appreciation for the fulfilling, albeit exhausting, work of building a meaningful business. This blend of skill mastery and thankfulness defines his entrepreneurial path.

Black Friday and the Failed Customer Experience

Tired of the relentless Black Friday hype? It's not just you. This once one-day shopping spree has morphed into a confusing, drawn-out affair. Originating in the 1950s US, Black Friday's global spread seemed like a win for deal-seeking shoppers. However, it's now more about boosting retail profits over an extended period. This shift dilutes its original purpose of adding value to customer experiences. Instead, it leaves many shoppers disappointed, erodes trust with misleading 'discounts', and fails to foster customer loyalty. Amidst financial strains, customers are scrutinizing deals more closely, and some are opting for Buy Nothing Days or #OptOutside movements. It's time for businesses to refocus on genuine customer relationships and experiences, moving away from revenue-driven tactics to truly enrich the holiday season.